Shine: Found Male in Taj Kumarakom
Anna: Nice shot!
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Thank you for the ID correction, Askar!
Dr.Jayaprakash V: You are right!
Thank you!
Andrew Simon: WOW!!!
Andrew Simon: So funny! :-)
Andrew Simon: Good shooting! This bird is one of my favorite!
Andrew Simon: Impressive photo!!!
Ashok Verma: How did you identify it to be Eastern Marsh harrier? Please specify.
Other sightings in India?
Jim Roosa: These are great photos. I have been birding in South America for the past year, and if I am reading this correctly, and it was considered a challenging day to view birds, then you have an embarrassment of riches in Kerala
Viktoriya: A very interesting and informative story. Thank you.
Vladilen: Beautiful
Ram Krishnan: Thank you. much appreciated.
Askar Isabekov: Dear Ram, I separated your series, please correct date and move the red marker to point of taking photos of each your series.
Аскар Исабеков: Thank you, Ram. I have a plan to visit Kerala once again, may be next year. Your info about bats is very interesting. Which species of bats you mean.
Ram: Birding in the area is still very very strong in December January. The Round, Vadakkechira and Puzhakkal being THE Spots.Hmmm, paradise flycatcher - the one i missed. Did spot a pair of wooly neck storks, open bills, ibis, peahen and chicks at Puzhakkal.You [....]
Jeby: I found this bee eater in my place
Kumily idukki
Askar Isabekov: This birds is not White-Eyed Buzzard, because adult White-Eyed Buzzards have pale eyes but don't have streaked underparts (photo), juvenile ones have dark eyes (photo). This bird is fist winter Common Buzzard (sample). [....]
伊莎贝尔科夫阿斯卡尔: This bird is Chestnut-Tailed Starling. Brahminy Starling in all plumages has dark cap in head.
DEBASISH MUKHERJEE: Thanks a lot Askar. I corrected the name.
Regards
Askar Isabekov: Dear DEBASISH MUKHERJEE, it's Common Sandpiper (Actitis hypoleucos)? plese note short legs.
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Thank you, Ashik!
You could very well be correct!
Regards,
Jp
Ashik: Little cormorant
Ashik: This is jerdon's bushlark for sure
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Awfully sorry!
I am still feeling my way around this site! Since there is no PM facility, I missed your note.
I shall be more careful in posting my images from now on..
Jp
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Thanks Pavel, for the input. Going by the distribution, Indian Bush lark is seen in north-western, central and south-central India while this bird was photographed in South India. I am wondering if this is the female of Ashy_crowned Sparrow Lark..Jp [....]
Askar Isabekov: Thank you very much, Pavel. I absolutely agree to you, bird has vey long legs to be intermedia.
Balachandran k v: Please provide entire indian bird pictures
Pavel Parkhaev: Hi Askar! This egret looks like Ardea alba (the skinny yellowish gap goes far behind the vertical line drawn trough the midle of the eye). According to the coloration of the feet (entire black), it can be A.a.modesta - Eastern Great Egret (this subspecies, [....]
Pavel Parkhaev: I suppose tha it can be Indian Bush Lark - Mirafra erythroptera
Humza: Hello mujhy yhi waly crow ka baby mila hai jo apny nest sy gir gya hai or uski ek tang bhi nhi hai jis sy wo srf apni ek tang sy beth pata hai to my usko apny ghr le ayi thi or phr meine usy bread ko pani my mila kr syringe sy khilaya hai q k uswaqt wo [....]
Аскар Исабеков: I moved series to unidentified birds
Dr.Jayaprakash V: You are right. Indian Blackbird it is.
Thank you.
Jp
Аскар Исабеков: that's description of nigropileus subspecies male. Please look to my photo of Indian Blackbird taken in Munnar (photo).
Аскар Исабеков: Dear Dr.Jayaprakash V, could you please publish photos of different dates and places in different series, because as you know birds can look different in different seasons. Thank you for sharing your nice photos!
Аскар Исабеков: Garganey
Аскар Исабеков: My dream
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Thank you for the suggestion!I found this in Birds of Indian Subcontinent, Grimmet & Inskipp Indian Blackbird “ ....(Males) have brownish slate-grey upper parts with darker brown to blackish crown and ear coverts resulting in capped effect....” [....]
Аскар Исабеков: Dark orange bill and orange eye-ring indicate to Indian Blackbird (Turdus simillimus) in my opinion.
Dr.Jayaprakash V: I think it is Common Blackbird (Turdus merula)
Experts please help with the ID.
Thanks,
Jp
Аскар Исабеков: i deleted duplicate image
Dr.Jayaprakash V: I posted the same image twice by mistake. And I do not know how to delete a post. Please help!
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Posting from archives - under lock down :-(
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Posting from archives. We are under strict lock down :-(
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Typical example of biting more than one can chew !
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Male.
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Female; Juvenile
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Seeing this for the first time. TFS!
Dr.Jayaprakash V: Thank you, Askar, for the clarification!
Jp
Dr.Jayaprakash V: If the ID is wrong, I request the experts to kindly correct me. Thank you!
Askar Isabekov: parroti is a subspecies (race) of Great Coucal. Lists of species of Birds of India (Wiki, Avibase) don't contain Southern Coucal as the full species. I agree to you, bird in your photo shows lack of rufous in mantle, it's a feature of parroti race. In [....]
Dibyendu Ash: How to rule out Thick-billed: No red bill base; rule out pin-tailed: Note the tail; Orange-breasted: note the rump, no gray tail
Dr.Jayaprakash V: I am not sure about the classification. To me this is Southern Coucal (C.(sinensis)parroti)Greater Coucal ( C.sinensis) is a resident of Pakistan, Himalayan foothills, northern Gangetic plains and Bangladesh, according to Grimmet & Inskipp.But I could [....]
Konstanyin Kovalev: https://indianbirds.club/v2taxon.php?s=1056&l=en
DEBASISH MUKHERJEE: I think it is Gray-banded Munia (Lonchura vana)
Вадим Ивушкин: Спасибо! Разобрался, мы почему-то на это внимание не обращали.
Askar Isabekov: спасибо, Вадим. но вот в том и прикол, что это такая московка - отличие от rubidiventris - это полоска белых точек на крыле. Это Periparus ater melanolophus. правда, [....]
Вадим Ивушкин: А чего в неопределенных?
Вадим Ивушкин: Аскар, с прошедшими праздниками! Тут в разделе под названием Московка все фотографии - Periparus rubidiventris. Лучше перенести. Московка выглядит по-другому [....]
Sergo Travelian: its Oriental magpie-robin (Copsychus saularis)
Askar Isabekov: White-cheeked Barbet?
Сергей Ефанов: Аскар!!!!!!! Ты дома то живешь?(шутка конечно)Я просто поражаюсь твоему перемещению, ты не сидишь на месте. Желаю тебе кругом и всюду только зеленый [....]
Shameem A.P: The images are awesome.
Аскар Исабеков: Hello Paul. I was in Kerala in Oct-Dec, it was a good time for birding. But I can to say nothing about birding in August, sorry. In August 2018 there was the big flood in Kerala, because a lot of showers, so I can guess August no so good time.
Paul: Hello Askar,I am really excited to see all the great pix and articles you have posted from South India. I am from Sri Lanka which is much smaller yet still full of birds.I generally do a little birding in Chennai, Mumbai and Kolkata in Dec-feb, but I [....]
Askar Isabekov: bird in link looks like Ashy Prinia
is this lesser whitethroat: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10213919291479665&set=a.3456149005715&type=3&theater
Elena Shnayder: Thanks!
Dibyendu Ash: Surely a Golden-fronted LB. In north-east Indian ssp. the amount of orange in the forecrown is more and in southern Indian nominate race it is less in contrast.
Elena Shnayder: I'd like to have some comments about my ID of this bird. I decided that's C.aurifrons based only on a bluish wash on the shoulders and a glimpse of gold on a forehead that is mostly out of sight. Are there other reliable features? Maybe a shape and a [....]
Elena Shnayder: I'm not 100% sure I made a correct ID of the species. Because of a very pale (pinkish) bill-tip, I have a doubt.
subramanya bhat: Is this bird in related with yaksha devathe?
Askar Isabekov: Malabar Whistling Thrush?
Amal: Study about common birds
Ahdrew Bazdyrev: Очень уж мощные клюв и ноги для индийской камышевки - скорее кто-то из тростниковых.
Sergey L. Volkov: Muscicapa sibirica: small bill, spotted breast.
Dhairya: Hi, thanks a lot for detailed explanation. I will point out that in rishad book, subspecies mentioned are f. C. Insignis and f. C. Pallidus. There is nothing mentioning about f. C. Lymani. Thanks for the help mate. Can you send some photo about merlin [....]
Askar Isabekov: The following is just my attempt to deep to theme. Firstly I looked the Merlin's page in avibase site, and tried to select the subspecies of eight ones which can be observed in India in winter time. I selected four subspecies from which aesalon and insignis [....]
Dhairya Dixit: Please suggest subspecies for all 3 different birds, thank you
Suresh Babu: We would like to know more about birds club and its activities and members
Please advise
Thanks
Askar Isabekov: Thank you, Demina! There is one bird in both photos. My guess is Rusty-tailed Flycatcher, but I'm not sure. It's better to hear the local experts opinion.
demina silva: it is a large billed crow
demina silva: it might be a roufus tailed scrub robin
demina silva: it might be a brown shrike juvenile.....
Askar Isabekov: Thanks Sergey!
Sergey L. Volkov: 13. Yeah, this is Funambulus palmarum.
Askar Isabekov: in 2nd and 3rd photos together with Brahminy Kite
Askar Isabekov: I saw how this Kingfisher caught the fish, then more than 20 minutes bird was static, probably it was waiting when the large fish die.
Askar Isabekov: two Darters were soaring above the city like eagles
Andrey Kovalenko: Это не orinus случайно...? Слишком крупный клюв.
Askar Isabekov: In 2nd photo there are Little (in top) and Indian (bottom) Cormorants. Little one is not so little.
Askar Isabekov: thanx! corrected
Askar Isabekov: top-left bird is Garganey
Sergey L. Volkov: Askar, no. 17 is not signed. Haliastur indus, Brahminy Kite.
Askar Isabekov: There are 4 or 5 different birds in series, all of them have almost pure grey mantle with a bit of rufous close tu rump
Andrew Simon: Sergey, I am sorry, but I have no other photoes. That is all.
Askar Isabekov: This Indian Pond Heron is in breeding plumage in the end of November.
Askar Isabekov: Thanks, Sanjik!
Askar Isabekov: Thanks!
sanzhar abdikhalyk: Pls check zitting cisticola
sanzhar abdikhalyk: Congratulations! You got him
Askar Isabekov: together with Jungle Mynas
Askar Isabekov: one more playing
Askar Isabekov: just playing time
Adhithyan: Indian cormorants. Longer thin beak and rounded head.
Askar Isabekov: Photos were taken from the opposite side of Puzhakkal river. Kingfisher caught crab and tried to eat it.
Askar Isabekov: Dear Lathish, glad to see you in site Kerala.Birds.Watch!
Could you move the red marker in your series to the point of photo shooting, please. You can do it in modal window which open if you clock "edit" button under the photo.
Askar Isabekov: Juv Peregrine Falcon caught Wood Sandpiper in Kole lands
Askar Isabekov: Thank you very much!
Adhithyan: In my opinion, the large raptor is an INDIAN SPOTTED EAGLE. It's difficult to differentiate from similar looking Greater spotted Eagle. Even though, longer gape line extending beyond the level of the middle of the pupil, pale brown thigh feathers and [....]
Askar Isabekov: In my opinion large one is Steppe Eagle by the barred PM and large mouth.
Sergey L. Volkov: It may be that it is a carrion crow. But I would like to see other photos.
Andrew Simon: May be Plain Prinia?
Andrew Simon: May be the same, Carrion Crow?
Andrew Simon: May be Carrion Crow?
Andrew Simon: It seems to me that this is not a Little Plower. May be Long-billed Plover?
Askar Isabekov: after 3 days in the same tree
Askar Isabekov: Спасибо!
Мадина Дюсебаева: Вау какая
Gennadiy Dyakin: Mykola, many thanks.
Askar Isabekov: Ashy Drongo?
Askar Isabekov: This one is female White-bellied Blue Flycatcher. It's really looks like Red-breasted Flycatcher but has reddish tail. Unfortunately I didn't watch male.
Askar Isabekov: Two Flycatchers were id by the friends from FB group. This one is Brown-breasted flycatcher. It resembles an Asian Brown Flycatcher, but this one has pale legs instead of black.
Vladislav Simonov: Golden-fronted Leafbird?
Askar Isabekov: Looks very similar to Red-breated or Taiga Flycatchers, but has not black and white but reddish tail. So my suggest is female of one of the Ficedula Flycatchers.
Askar Isabekov: One of the small Muscicapa Flycatchers, probably Asian Brown one.
Askar Isabekov: have no any idea
Askar Isabekov: very short tail, slightly-curved bill, pale underparts and brownish upperparts. is it Nilgiri Flowerpecker?
Oleg Belyalov: !!!
Mykola Skyrpan: Bird that in flight is juvenile Eastern Imperial Eagle
Oleg Belyalov: cristatus
Vladislav Simonov: Выглядит как просто "шрайк".)) Жулан какой-то.
Vladislav Simonov: Спасибо, Сергей! Похоже так и есть. Другие виды, наверное, только в Гималаях. Ранее эта птица проходила в оперативных сводках под псевдонимом [....]
Сергей Л. Волков: Чечевица. Обыкновенная как будто. Наверное, наша зимующая. Не знаю, могут ли там быть похожие виды.
Аскар Исабеков: согласен, значит вытянулась так, что не узнал. спасибо, Владислав.
Vladislav Simonov: А желтое пятно на голове у кого ещё может быть?
Askar Isabekov: эта заметно крупнее, она размером со змеешейку, с которой рядом сидела
Vladislav Simonov: Вроде обычная египетская цапля.
Askar Isabekov: Means new birds in my Indian list of birds
Gennadiy Dyakin: Askar, how the Barn Swallow can be a laifer for you if it is a common bird in Kazakhstan?
Gennadiy Dyakin: Askar, I saw the majority of these birds, therefore I thought you saw them too.
Oleg Belyalov: Thank you! I'll sleep peacefully. I was very frightened, thinking that the sign is the blue iris of the eyes. So it is drawn in the guide. And I did not attach importance.
Askar Isabekov: Thanks, Gena. During last four days I have 10 lifers (can view in my personal page): 1. Brahminy Kite (2017-10-21)2. Blue-tailed Bee-eater (2017-10-21)3. Black-hooded Oriole (2017-10-21)4. Oriental Honey-buzzard (2017-10-21)5. Greater Racket-tailed Drongo [....]
Askar Isabekov: Oleg, birds in your photos have dark lores and forehaed, the features od Jungle Babbler.
Oleg Belyalov: Askar, now I doubt which bird I saw on February 5, 2012 in Goa. Look, maybe it's not a Jungle Babbler and a Yellow-billed Babbler
Gennadiy Dyakin: I congratulate! Is this your first lifer for this trip?
Askar Isabekov: The new species for me. Firstly I think it'd Jungle Babbler then found info that its Yellow-billed of White-headed Babbler. Last name is better to me.
Vladislav Simonov: Это за 2 поездки в 2010 в Гоа и в 2012 в северную Индию с заездом на 2 дня в горы.
Gennadiy Dyakin: 177 видов это хороший материал. В том числе на этот сайт добавились 21. И география смотрю обширная - от Гималаев до Гоа. Я не обратил внимание, [....]
Vladislav Simonov: Гид был не очень квалифицированным.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Просто мы в Биканире на свалке видели десятки степняков, и не могли уверенно среди них выделить rapax, и наш местный бердинг-гид тоже. Но раз [....]
Vladislav Simonov: Геннадий, благодарю за приветствие! Выложил все что было по Индии.
Vladislav Simonov: Честно говоря, полной уверенности у меня нет. В стаде орлов он выделялся очень светлой палевой окраской в отличии от темно-коричневых степных. [....]
Gennadiy Dyakin: Владислав, а как Вы его отличаете от Steppe Eagle?
Gennadiy Dyakin: Владислав, я рад, что Вы присоединились к нашему проекту!Вижу, что за неделю выложили множество фото, из которых много отличных, а некоторые [....]
Vladislav Simonov: Indian Jungle Crow
Vladislav Simonov: Parus melanolophus
Vladislav Simonov: Крачка Берга - Sterna bergii - Great Crested Tern и Малая хохлатая крачка - Sterna bengalensis - Lesser Crested Tern
Vladislav Simonov: Китайская иволга - Oriolus chinensis - Black-Naped Oriole и Черноголовая иволга - Oriolus xanthornus - Black-Hooded Oriole
Vladislav Simonov: +
Vladislav Simonov: +
Vladislav Simonov: +
Gennadiy Dyakin: Brown-headed Barbet (Megalaima zeylanica)
Oleg Belyalov: Точно. Не посмотрел)
Gennadiy Dyakin: Так самка alboides в определителе и нарисована с белым подбородком.
Oleg Belyalov: Motacilla alba alboides - почему то с белым горлом
Gennadiy Dyakin: Ну вот, рухнула последняя надежда. Кстати, это как раз у того плодового дерева, которое перед камнями . Получается у меня короткоклювого нет, [....]
Vassiliy Fedorenko: Scarlet.
Vassiliy Fedorenko: Nope, long-tailed again!
Dibyendu Ash: Yes this is Scarlet. Agree with Vassiliy; wingbar has 'S' marking. Long-tailed will have 'π' and short-billed will have '7' marking.
Gennadiy Dyakin: И еще одного нашел, которого не выкладывал из-за плохого качества. Но теперь уже стало интересно. Красных пятен вроде как нет, значит не скарлет. [....]
Gennadiy Dyakin: Вот тот бесхвостый, которого я упоминал. Ракурсы конечно неудачные, но на 2-м фото вроде как видны красные пятна, про которые упоминал Василий, [....]
Gennadiy Dyakin: Так то-то и оно, что скарлет появился в нашем трип-листе только в последний день 2 декабря, а до этого все определялись как два других вида, [....]
Oleg Belyalov: Гена, посмотри своих с первой локации. 27-29. Возле фруктового дерева крутились. Тамя смотрел на крыло, чтобы понять отличие от длиннохвостого. [....]
Oleg Belyalov: Я снимал личинкоедов в трёх местах. В одном не видно крыльев и он неопределим. В двух других случаях был Scarlet. Но так его определил я сам и Дибс [....]
Vassiliy Fedorenko: Да, Скарлет. Среди тех, что выкладывала Тоня, короткоклювого тоже не было.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Я очень попадаю под давление авторитетов. А в поле их всех Дибс называл короткоклювыми, так что под этими названиями и выкладывал, хотя после [....]
Vassiliy Fedorenko: Ну нет у короткоклювого красных концов маховых :)
Gennadiy Dyakin: Thank you.
Gennadiy Dyakin: OK. Thank you, Vasiliy.
Vassiliy Fedorenko: And this is a Long-tailed by the red mirror.
Vassiliy Fedorenko: I think it's a Skarlet. Because Short-billed don't have a hook at the end of the bill. Besides your bird have red spots at the end of primary feathers.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Yes, I know. But I don't see this species in list of birds on this web-site. I think there are sinonims. I think you write about White-eared bulbul.
sanzhar abdikhalyk: Himalayan bulbul. Note the curving crest. White-cheeked bulbul crest almost invisible.
sanzhar abdikhalyk: I believe this is a bronze-winged jacana juvenile. Note a flash of emerald color on the back, lack of black lore and black stripe along the neck
sanzhar abdikhalyk: Common tailorbird. Small size, pinkish legs, olive-yellowish back and affinity to human settlement.
Andrew Simon: Is it possible to identify this bird?
Gennadiy Dyakin: Thank you, Oleg and Vasiliy. I replaced this one to Ph. pulcher.
Oleg Belyalov: Pycnonotus cafer humayuni
Oleg Belyalov: Pycnonotus cafer bengalensis
Олег Белялов: Гена у Ashy-throated Warbler голова вообще серая и бровь белая. В этом она аналог по расцветке Grey-hooded Warbler, только у этой крыло чистое. Это не поймёшь [....]
Gennadiy Dyakin: На картинках и у pulcher, и у chloronotus шапочка почти такого же цвета, как спина, зеленоватая. А у maculipensis гораздо темнее спины. Так вот на этом фото [....]
Vassiliy Fedorenko: The Lemon-rumped Warbler has a white stripe on the wing instead of yellow.
Oleg Belyalov: There are many options. Lemon-rumped Warbler Phylloscopus chloronotus ?
Vassiliy Fedorenko: Phylloscopus pulcher
Dibyendu Ash: Again this one is a c.discolor. Sikkim Treecreeper.
Dibyendu Ash: light creamy throat and breast of cerhis nipalensis; is a clear distinguishing mark from Certhis discolor. C.discolor will have warm buffish throat and belly.
In my opinion it is a Rusty-flanked Treecreeper (also known as Certhia nipalensis)
Dibyendu Ash: Buffish brown throat and breast of cerhis discolor; is a clear distinguishing mark from Certhis nipalensis.
In my opinion it is a Sikkim Treecreeper (also known as Brown-throated Tree creeper; also known as Certhia discolor)
Oleg Belyalov: Motacilla (alba) personata
Belyalov Oleg: Motacilla alba leucopsis
sanzhar abdikhalyk: Cattle egret. You can still see vestiges of breeding plumage (rufous colour on top of head)
Andrew Simon: Is seems to me, that the bird was rather small. I have added some more pictures.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Great Egret (Ardea alba)
Gennadiy Dyakin: White Wagtail (Motacilla alba)
Gennadiy Dyakin: Jungle Babbler (Turdoides striata)
Gennadiy Dyakin: Asian Koel (Eudynamys scolopaceus)
Vassiliy Fedorenko: I think it's Sikkim Treecreeper (Certhia discolor) because of red tail and narrow eyebrow.
mr t: call 0974 77828785 // 0097455805519 **WE PROVIDE QATARI SPONSOR WHO WANT TO OPEN NEW BUSINESS FROM DOHA QATAR OR UAE OR ANY EUROPE ETC, OUR RATE IS VERY CHEAP MONTHLY FESS WE WILL GIVEYOUR FULL EXCESS IF ANY WANTS TO OPEN NEW BUSINESS CAN CONTACT MOBILE [....]
Tatiana Petrova: Спасибо :) Фото очень много, только вот загружать сюда по штучке очень долго.. Буду стараться загрузить побольше...
Gennadiy Dyakin: Татьяна, приветствуем Вас на сайте! Мы рады, что после некоторого сонного периода сайт снова оживает. Особенно радует, что Вы добавили фото [....]
Askar Isabekov: Thanks Tatiana
Tatiana Petrova: Shikra - red eyes, no stripes on tail
Dibyendu Ash: Some White-throat. Most likely Hume's White-throat
Dibyendu Ash: Variegated Laughingthrush
Vladilen: Nice shot!
Belyalov Oleg: Superb
Askar Isabekov: Dear Dibyendu, welcome to the Indian Birds Club!
Askar Isabekov: Fantastic photo! I hope I ever see this bird.
Ashok Kumar Kashyap: Nice Photo
Karassev Vladilen: Beautiful!
Vladilen: Each of your object has a character!
Gennadiy Dyakin: Thank you, Steve.
Steve Botham: One feature not mentioned, Taiga has obvious pronounced black uppertail coverts and on this bird they are same colour as back. Also bill would be all dark and red bordered by grey breast band, a good Red Breasted Flycatcher Gennadiy
Steve Botham: Hume's Warbler, phylloscopus humei
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Great shot!
As I see in vain we did not go to the park. Although with our intuziazma we definitely would be eaten :)
Belyalov Oleg: Very great success
Gennadiy Dyakin: I replace this birds to Clamorous Reed-Warbler.
Soumyajit Nandy: Askar, your email id please!
Soumyajit Nandy: coming soon Gennadiy :)
Gennadiy Dyakin: Nice photo. Soumyajit, we wait your photo of Black Bittern.
Isabekov Askar: Soumyajit, nice shot!
Could you send me photo of this bird in 640x480 resolution to make the frontispiece of species.
Gennadiy Dyakin: What about this bird? We didn't solve on it. May be to place in unidentified ?
Gennadiy Dyakin: Oleg, correct the date, please.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Awesome!
Isabekov Askar: please check the date. we were in Keoladeo at 15-16 of January.
Soumyajit Nandy: I guess calidus ssp.
Garg Sudhir: Thanks a lot please. .
Isabekov Askar: Grey head and pale lower mandible are additional features of species not only to breeding male but to the birds in all the rest plumages.
Isabekov Askar: I taken photos of this bird too, it shows more red on breast on other photos.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Why so small red on a breast?
Askar Isabekov: Genndy, this bird is not Taiga Flycatcher. Please note the grey head and pale lower mandible.
Sanzhar Abdikhalyk: Dear Sudhir-ji! On behalf of indianbirds.club team my warmest welcome to our community! It is great to have you with us and super-great to start your membership off with such a great sighting!all the best and look forward to many more of your valuable [....]
Oleg Belyalov: My congratulations! It's very rare vagrant far to the South.
Isabekov Askar: imho Green Sandpiper
Isabekov Askar: Spotted breast and chestnut crown indicate to Spanish Sparrow.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Эх, Владилен... Не дождался я пока ты своих гусей выложишь, пришлось самому ехать фотать...
Gennadiy Dyakin: I agree with Askar.
Isabekov Askar: Jungle Prinia has downturned large bill, noticable neck. On some photos Jungle prinia looks like Babler. Bird on photo is not Jungle Prinia but Plain one.
Gennadiy Dyakin: I place to Blue-capped Redstart.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Thank you.
Isabekov Askar: Shikra or Eurasian Sparrowhawk? Or Chinese Sparrowhawk?
Isabekov Askar: Female Blue-capped Redstart
Isabekov Askar: Chiffchaff
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Das ist Calidris alpina!
The beak not so long but this is it.
Sanzhar Abdikhalyk: I believe that this could be jungle prinia. The underparts of plain prinia are more whitish-buff. Я думаю, что это вполне может быть джунглевая приния. Не буроголовая (plain). У джунглевой [....]
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Askar, what for did you removed russian names of birds?
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Here she is a Acrocephalus, but at birs.kz has stand Lusciniola.)
By the way, there is a mistake in the Helm guide, it is showed with yellow legs.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Good one! I saw it only in fragments.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Quality is better and better)
Fedorenko Vassiliy: What's the prob? Tarsiger cyanurus IMO.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Yea, there is a similarity. But this one have no any colors. And it's not because of fog.
Isabekov Askar: This bird is Gray-capped Woodpecker. Brown-capped Woodpecker has spotted tail.
Isabekov Askar: This bird is very similar to Bunting taken in mountains - photo.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Sorry, read 'note' like 'not' :)
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Actually rump is reddish in fact on the 2nd photo. It's our bird but looks unfamilliar.. smaller. May be another subspecies?
Isabekov Askar: note the reddish rump indicating to female Blue-capped Redstart
Fedorenko Vassiliy: For Chestnut-eared Bunting location is not suitable.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: leucocephala also has this spot.
Probably it's Bunting not so clear, therefor have no colors.
And by the way, leucocephalA )
Isabekov Askar: the little white spot below the ear probably indicate to Chestnut-eared Bunting
Isabekov Askar: need to ask Soumyajit because this bird doesn't show the clear features of any species. be careful with little brown birds ))
Gennadiy Dyakin: По-моему эта та-же птица, что в неопределенных у Васи. Может такой ракурс чем-то поможет.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Heh.. It's like looking in the mirror.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Oops.. I don't check fucata previously.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Thanks, I replace to Aberrant Bush-Warbler.
Gennadiy Dyakin: Больше никаких мнений не услышал, так что перемещаю в индийские.
Gennadiy Dyakin: I place to Plain Prinia.
Isabekov Askar: ... because I am not sure in stewarti
Isabekov Askar: I posted question on Birdforum.net.
Isabekov Askar: Aberrant Bush-Warbler is a quite good candidate. Compare with sample 1 and sample 2 birds. [....]
Khaydarov David: Agree with Askar. I'd say Aberrant Bush-Warbler (Cettia flavolivacea).
Isabekov Askar: Long tail, lack of pale supercillium and dark lores indicate to Plan Prinia.
Isabekov Askar: Thank you Vassily.
Isabekov Askar: answer form Jalid: These are Grey-breasted Prinias: smaller, with smaller bill, dark loral stripe, narrow supercilium almost like in Phylloscopus warbler (in winter), brownish wings almost like in Whitethroat and more distinct black bands on the underside [....]
Isabekov Askar: Dark lores, pale supercillium, reddish wings indicate to Grey-breasted Prinia.
Isabekov Askar: Dark lores, white supercillium, dark bands on undertail indicate to Grey-breasted Prinia.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: This is the female of Rufous-gorgeted Flycatcher. Like this one.
Владислав Симонов: Индийские бакланы.
Владислав Симонов: Странная птица. Определенно какая-то альципа, но идеально ни к одной не подходит. Предположу непальскую Alcippe nepalensis. Не хватает правда темной [....]
Sanzhar Abdikhalyk: Askar. You got the male in this picture!
Isabekov Askar: Thanks Sanzhar.
Isabekov Askar: Jungle Owlet
Isabekov Askar: Wow! Nice shot!
Isabekov Askar: Slaty-blue Flycatcher has thin bill. this one has more stronger bill. It is female Grey Bushchat.
Sanzhar Abdikhalyk: Even though it's common, it's nonetheless stunningly beautiful!
Sanzhar Abdikhalyk: I believe this is a grey-breasted prinia, owing to the dark markings at the underside of the tail feathers. No other prinia in that area has those to my knowledge. It should be noted that this is winter non-breeding plumage. In breeding plumage the breast [....]
Gennadiy Dyakin: I place to stewarti, if there is no other opinion.
Isabekov Askar: I have asked help on BirdForum.net
Isabekov Askar: looks very long-tailed to be Leaf Warbler.
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Common Rosefinch
Fedorenko Vassiliy: Good shot!
I think another photo can be deleted. At least mine exactly. The same birds, the same angle.
© Askar Isabekov
2017-12-02
Eravikulam National Park. Munnar, Kerala.
© Garg Sudhir
2015-02-14
Mangalsar Dam ( Mansarover) Tehla Village, Alwar Dist, Rajasthan, India
2020-04-14. Hoopoe (Dr.Jayaprakash V).
2020-04-10. Indian Silverbill (Dr.Jayaprakash V).
2020-03-30. Large Grey Babbler (Dr.Jayaprakash V).